09232015InvestigatingAndDefendingTheGospels#3DonRuhl
Investigating and Defending the Gospels #3
Using Circumstantial Evidence
Don Ruhl • Savage Street, Grants Pass, Oregon • August 19, In the year of our Lord, 2015
Prelude:
- Two Kinds of Evidence:
- Direct
- Proves something by itself
- Witnesses
- Circumstantial (Indirect)
- By itself does not prove anything.
- Joined with other pieces of evidence points to a particular conclusion.
- Direct
Persuasion:
- The Universe Had a Beginning
- Even atheists acknowledge this truth.
- However, what triggered it?
- Whatever caused it,
- set in motion an amazing chain of events!
- Do you realize how many things fell into place
- from that beginning to enable you to be present today?
- Is it feasible that the universe could have caused itself to be?
- Have we documented anything that caused itself to come into existence?
- Truly, an uncaused first cause has to exist.
- Do you understand the awesome power that it must have had?
- If at one time, nothing existed,
- why are we even here now?
- “Why is there something rather than nothing?” (Gottfried Leibniz).
- Is the following reasonable?
- Anything that exists had a cause.
- The universe exists.
- Therefore, the universe had a cause.
- The cause had to be greater than the universe,
- making the cause eternal and uncaused.
- God is the most reasonable explanation
- as the uncaused first cause.
- The Universe Has the Appearance of Design
- That design: To support life
- The universe, especially Earth, shows design for supporting life.
- Can you name some?
- How could the universe, especially Earth,
- accidentally bring so many forces together,
- working harmoniously to support life?
- Is it possible? Yes.
- Is it reasonable? No.
- Truly,
15 May you be blessed by the Lord,
Who made heaven and earth.
(Psa 115.15)
- Remember The Anthropic Principle.
- The Universe Has Life
- Does the human body exhibit design?
- Think of the body’s numerous systems and
- that they all work together to give us life.
- We have invented robots that can
- stand,
- walk,
- run,
- jump, and even
- ride a bicycle.
- Can we say that intelligence made such robots?
- Does the human body, or any living specimen, surpass
- the ability of modern robots?
- See Psalm 139.13–16.
- We have invented robots that can
- What is DNA?
- It carries all the genetic information your body needs to make you.
- Is it possible to have
- a self-replicating information system
- without an intelligence that designed it?
- Does the human body exhibit design?
- The Universe Has Objective Morality
- Can we say that law is greater than any one person?
- What is that law?
- From where did it come?
- If God does not exist, who came up with this law?
- Under what law were—and sometimes still are—Nazis prosecuted?
- Someone might say, “International Law.”
- But from where did we get International Law?
- Eventually we come down to belief in God.
- If evolution is true,
- what determines what we do and don’t do?
- It is nothing more than chemical processes.
- This destroys free will.
- It also destroys accountability.
- Some have come up with an evolutionary basis for rape.
- Think about it:
- atheism and evolution have taken over society.
- Society is getting more into the treatment of criminals
- rather than repentance.
- Why is that?
Conclusion:
- We cannot really say that one argument makes the point, but
- we put them all together and
- they all point to the existence of a power and intelligence
- that supersedes the universe, and
- who created the universe.
- This is circumstantial evidence,
- which can be stronger than direct evidence, or witnesses.
- Peter makes this argument in Second Peter 1.16–21.
- See the marginal note on verse 19 of the NKJV.
- Why is it that the word of prophecy is more sure than seeing?