Download the Notes:
12172017WhatIsHellPart1DonRuhl
What Is Hell? Part 1
Is it the grave or eternal fire?
Don Ruhl • Savage Street, Grants Pass, Oregon • December 17, In the year of our Lord, 2017
Prelude:
- Our friends in the Watchtower Society,
- commonly known as “Jehovah’s Witnesses,”
- teach many strange doctrines,
- including that hell is merely the grave.
- Therefore, when you die,
- you cease to exist.
- At the resurrection,
- you will be raised temporarily
- to hear their message again.
- If you reject it again,
- you die again with no hope of a future second resurrection.
- I love these people, but
- they have various doctrinal issues that you would not pick up on your own.
- You have to have someone teaching you their doctrines.
- The biggest problem with their teaching of hell
- is that they equate hell with Hades or Sheol.
- They believe Hades (NT) and Sheol (OT) simply refer to the grave and
- they believe hell also refers to the grave.
- They have two underlying positions that lead them to this conclusion:
- They appeal to your feelings saying that God would never cast anyone into hellfire and
- they believe the dead have no conscious awareness.
- I will be quoting from one of their books, “Make Sure of All Things Hold Fast to What Is Fine.”
Persuasion:
- State of the Dead
- The JW position:“Impossible for the Dead to Be Tormented; They Are Unconscious”
“The soul itself is dead”
- Ecc 9.5, 10For the living know that they will die;
But the dead know nothing,
And they have no more reward,
For the memory of them is forgotten.
(Ecclesiastes 9.5)Whatever your hand finds to do, do it with your might; for there is no work or device or knowledge or wisdom in the grave where you are going (Ecclesiastes 9.10).
- Psa 146.4
- Psa 31.17
- Eze 18.4, 20
- Matt 26.36, 38
- Acts 3.23
- Ecc 9.5, 10For the living know that they will die;
- Refutation:
- Ecc 9.5 also says the dead also have no more reward, but
- the JWs do believe that they do.
- They fail to understand that Solomon looks at life under the sun.
- 29x Solomon alerts us that he speaks of life under the sun.
- Consider just two of them.
- Ecclesiastes 1.3 introduces how he will speak,What profit has a man from all his labor
In which he toils under the sun?
(Ecclesiastes 1.3)- Solomon was not attempting to teach
- the soul does not exist after death.
- He is going to show you the vanity of life under the sun
- without including God in your view of things.
- Then consider what immediately follows 9.5,Also their love, their hatred, and their envy have now perished;
Nevermore will they have a share
In anything done under the sun.
(Ecclesiastes 9.6)- JWs believe they will live again under the sun, but
- this says they will never have a share in anything done under the sun.
- Ecclesiastes 1.3 introduces how he will speak,What profit has a man from all his labor
- You cannot pull out verses here and there and ignore
- the immediate context,
- the context and literary style of that Bible Book, and
- the Bible as a whole.
- And Ecclesiastes 9.10 only makes a point that this life is your only chance.
- Once you die,
- your eternal destiny has been sealed.
- Ecc 9.5 also says the dead also have no more reward, but
- The JW position:“Impossible for the Dead to Be Tormented; They Are Unconscious”
- Translation Problems
- KJV of 1611 leads them in their misinterpretation.
- Hell in 1611 meant hole, or covered pit; grave
- Hades meant the place of departed spirits
- Gehenna (hell) meant the place of torment for the wicked.
- However, the KJV translated the Greek words and the Hebrew with one word, “Hell.”
- So what they do is take the ancient definition of hell, “the grave,” and
- apply it to the Greek words Hades and Gehenna and
- to the Hebrew word Sheol.
- However, you will read in your Bible
- the words “grave” and “tomb.”
- The Greeks had a different word for grave and tomb, mnhmei√on.
- It comes from a word that means memory or monument.
- When Greek writers in the New Testament said grave or tomb,
- they did not use the word hades or gehenna,
- nor the Hebrew Sheol.
- Thus, Hades and Gehenna refer to something else.
- Hades refers to the place of departed spirits.
- Gehenna has a background in the Valley of Hinnom.
- Jesus used that valley where they burned the trash
- to symbolize what hell is.
- KJV of 1611 leads them in their misinterpretation.
- The Upright Go to Hell?
- The JW position:“Upright as well as wicked people go to hell”
- Psa 16.10For You will not leave my soul in Sheol [Hell, KJV – NIV misses],
Nor will You allow Your Holy One to see corruption.
(Psalms 16.10) - Gen 37.34–35
- Job 14.13
- Psa 9.17
- Psa 16.10For You will not leave my soul in Sheol [Hell, KJV – NIV misses],
- Refutation:
- This stems from their confusion over the original language and their modern English equivalents.
- The JW position:“Upright as well as wicked people go to hell”
- Deliverance from Hell?
- The JW position:“Hope held out for those in hell; deliverance possible”
- Acts 2.31–32
- Rev 1.18
- Hos 13.14
- Rev 20.13
- The JW position:“Hope held out for those in hell; deliverance possible”
- How the Bible Uses “Life”
- The JW position:“Scriptures contrast life and death, not life in happiness and life in torment”
- Deu 30.15, 19“See, I have set before you today life and good, death and evil…” (Deuteronomy 30.15).
- Pro 18.21
- 1Jo 3.14
- 2Co 4.12
- It does not ever speak of existence in hell as life. Have you wondered why?
- The JW position:“Scriptures contrast life and death, not life in happiness and life in torment”
Exhortation:
- First Point
Don, this is supposed to be part 2 but is part 1. Where is part 2?
Excellent sermon.
Linda
I goofed when I titled this post as Part 2. It has not been corrected to say Part 1. This past Lord’s Day, January 14th, I preached Part 2 and it will be up in a few weeks. As you can tell, I am behind in posting. Thanks for your kind word.